7 Rated Books Book Reviews

Book Review: Tankborn by Karen Sandler

Title: Tankborn

Author: Karen Sandler

Genre: Dystopia, Science Fiction, Young Adult

Publisher: Tu Books
Publication Date: October 2011
Hardcover: 373 Pages

Best friends Kayla and Mishalla know they will be separated for their Assignments. They are GENs, Genetically Engineered Non-humans, and in their strict caste system, GENs are at the bottom rung of society. GENs are gestated in a tank and sent to work as slaves as soon as they reach age fifteen.

When Kayla is Assigned to care for Zul Manel, the patriarch of a trueborn family, she finds secrets and surprises; not least of which is her unexpected friendship with Zul’s great-grandson. Meanwhile, the children that Mishalla is Assigned to care for are being stolen in the middle of the night.

After weeks of toiling in their Assignments, mystifying circumstances enable Kayla and Mishalla to reunite. Together they hatch a plan to save the disappearing children. Yet can GENs really trust humans? Both girls must put their lives and hearts at risk to crack open a sinister conspiracy, revealing secrets no one is ready to face.

Stand alone or series: Stand alone novel (but maybe there’s more in the future set in this world?)

How did I get this book: Bought

Why did I read this book: To be honest, I was turned off by the kitschy cover (what is with all the bubbles?! They are all over the text of the book too, which is bizarre). BUT, when I started to read reviews praising the science fiction, the writing, and, most importantly, the awesomely diverse-minded worldbuilding, I was so very in.


On the distant world of Loka, lightyears away from Earth, humanity has changed. Separated into distinct, non-transmutable castes, Lokans run the spectrum from trueborn humans of untainted DNA and significant wealth to lowborn humans living in shanties and working menial jobs. At the very bottom of the hierarchy of power are the GENs – tankborns with human and animal DNA, as well as some machine integration, noted by a telltale tattoo on their right cheek. Every GEN is also enhanced with a special skill set (a “sket”), that will determine where they will work once they come of assignment age.

Kayla and her best friend Mishalla are both GENs from the same lowlying sector, Chadi. The slightly elder Mishalla is assigned to be a nurturer in a district thousands of kilometers away, and shortly after Kayla is assigned to be a private elderly caretaker for a wealthy trueborn family – and though the girls believe that they might never see each other again, their destinies are inextricably linked. While Mishalla is heartbroken as night after night her charges are taken away by lowborn nurturers, Kayla learns that her own charge, Zul Manel, has secrets from his past and plans for the future that will rock the very foundations of society. With the unexpected help of a trueborn human, Zul’s grandson Devak, and a lowborn human named Eoghan, Kayla and Mishalla will change everything.

I’m of two minds when it comes to Tankborn. The most important thing to say is: I absolutely head-over-heels LOVE the world that Ms. Sandler has created. Lee and Low books is a publisher dedicated to diversity and publishing books that feature or are by people of color, and Tankborn lives up to that mission with its fascinating, imaginative, and wonderfully diverse world. The society on Loka is stratified into different castes, with trueborns ranked high with their dark skin and diamond bali earrings, and lowborns with their paler skin and lower grade balis denoting status. GENs, not even considered human, are naught more than slaves, utterly deprived of basic rights and freedoms. Even more, the GEN belief system is a religion that glorifies in an ultimate, infinite being that has created trueborns and lowborns, and the GENs to serve them. And the coolest thing about this rigid social strata? None of it feels forced or overt – there is subtlety in Ms. Sandler’s writing, which is incredibly refreshing and appreciated, especially in a subgenre (YA SciFi Dystopia) that is chock-full of sledgehammer-technique message-making. There is an utter convincingness to this world order and cultural system that is both familiar, in those glimpses taken from aspects of human history, and alien.

In the same vein, the technological aspects of the world are believable (within the realm of science fiction, of course) with limitations, explanations, and technology that makes sense. The concept of GENs with their “annexed” and “bare” brains – where their machine integration allows the annexed portions to be programmed, and their biological portions to behave as a regular human brain would – is fascinating. The GEN tattoos that allow for the interfacing of technology to biology is an interesting conceit, and though the human-machine is a science fiction standby, Tankborn does so much to distinguish itself from the tired Cyborg routine by virtue of its complex social world.

I did mention that I am of two minds when it comes to Tanborn, though, all praises said. While I was completely won over by the intricate details and flawless worldbuilding, I felt underwhelmed by the actual plot and characters. The overarching story is meant to follow dual protagonists Kayla and Mishalla, but in practice the story is far more lopsided, as Kayla is undoubtedly our primary protagonist, with Mishalla’s story is interspliced every four or five chapters. As characters, Kayla is our clumsy heroine with physical strength as her sket and some emotional strength to match. Mishalla is similarly good-hearted and generally amiable. The thing is though, both characters lack bite. They are empathetic and we can feel for them as they struggle against a world in which they are controlled and mistreated, but there’s nothing particularly interesting or distinctive about either character. The story, too, is muted and lethargic, with the main conflict focused on the mysterious disappearing children, and a group of people that have approached Kayla and Mishalla (as well as other GENs) and have appropriated some of their programming and given them tech to hide and to pass on. Much of the novel is actually focused on Kayla as she struggles in her new role as Zul’s caregiver, and her burgeoning relationship with Devak, both of whom figure into the much larger plot. There are some revelations that happen in the last act of the novel, lackluster and somewhat trite.

Overall, Tankborn has a lot going for it – a beautifully developed world, a society that is culturally detailed, and a scifi background that abides by set rules. On the other hand, the characters are a little underdeveloped, the story lacking direction and ultimately coming to a slightly disappointing conclusion. Ultimately, though, Tankborn‘s strengths outweigh its shortcomings, and I know that I’ll be on the lookout for more books by Karen Sandler in the future.

Notable Quotes/Parts: You can read the first four chapters of Tankborn online HERE.

Rating: 7 – Very Good, but only really because of the stellar worldbuilding

Buy the Book:

Ebook available for kindle US, nook & apple

You Might Also Like


  • Caro
    March 30, 2012 at 2:26 pm

    When I read the title Tankborn, I immediately thought of the TV series from 1995/96 Space: Above & Beyond (by James Wong & Glen Morgan of The X-Files fame) because they had characters who were In-Vitros or ‘Tanks’ because they gestated in a tank and came out as adults. *sigh* I miss that show.
    Anyway, this sounds very interesting and well worth a read.

    Can I also just say that I love reading the reviews? I’m on a book buying embargo at the moment (thank you space and financial constraints but it’s not like I don’t have any books to read here in the house!) so I kind of live vicariously through this site and still get to hear what’s going on in the book world!

  • Heidi
    March 30, 2012 at 7:52 pm

    Hmm…I’m torn on this one. I was turned off by the cover as well, but the fact that it is a standalone, has unique diversity and strong world building makes it tempting despite your reservations about the characters. I suppose I’ll try out the first few chapters and see how I feel!

  • Thea
    March 31, 2012 at 5:46 am

    Late to the party!

    Caro – YES! That is such an apt comparison! I totally remember Space: Above & Beyond. I think you’ll like Tankborn, even if some elements are weak, the world is so strong it more than compensates. Also, totally happy to help you live vicariously 🙂 Now, you need an e-reader to help make space 😉

    Heidi – The cover is just awful. I love the model they have chosen for Kayla, but the colors, the bizarre bubbles, the invitro babies in the bubbles…it’s not a good mix. That said, the cohesiveness of the cultural, social, and SF elements in Tankborn are so well done, I want EVERYONE to read it 😀 No pressure.

  • Jodie
    March 31, 2012 at 7:53 am

    I was also split on this book – negatives and positives are better than all megatives I suppose though. Re the cover I have a really hard time believing that the GENs tattoos are designed so prettily and that there’s tech that can synch up to the lines. So I spent the whole book imagining that tattoo differently, but that Kayla looked like the girl on the cover.

  • Caro
    March 31, 2012 at 3:40 pm

    Thea, the sad thing is I do have an e-reader! But I had to quit buying books for it because I have a pile of them on my external hard drive and my credit card was beginning to glow from the amount of use it was getting online. Heh.
    Regardless, I love knowing what new books are out there to see if there is something that I really should buy so again thank you for helping me to keep informed.

Leave a Reply