7 Rated Books Book Reviews

Book Review: Broken by Susan Jane Bigelow

Title: Broken

Author: Susan Jane Bigelow

Genre: Dystopian / Fantasy / Superheroes

Publisher: Candlemark & Gleam
Publication date: January 2011
Ebook: 340 pages

In a post-war future world where First Contact has been made, humans are colonizing the stars, and the nations of Earth have been united under a central government, Extrahumans are required by law to belong to the Union. When a young man with visions of the future sets out on a mission to define the course of human history, he encounters a devastated former hero, a fascist dictatorship bent on world domination, and the realities of living in a society where affiliation is everything.

Stand alone or series: Stand alone but hopefully the beginning of a beautiful series?

How did I get this book: Got a review copy from the publisher.

Why did I read this book: I was offered a review copy and accepted on the strength of the cover (isn’t it great? And sad? It is a sad cover to me) and the blurb: plus I love superheroes!


Broken still remembers how it used to feel being able to fly: not only that but also how it felt to be really fast and how it was all just so effortless. It was pure joy to fly, to float like that, so thank goodness that her memory is not that good, that she hardly ever remembers that feeling. A former super-hero called Silverwyng, an Extrahuman affiliated with the Union, she lost her ability to fly one day and ever since then has been living in the streets, getting by, being forgotten and forgetting, irreparably… broken.

And then one day, this young kid named Michael shows up looking for Silverwyng, carrying a baby in his arms, a baby who according to Michael’s own Extrahuman ability to see the future, is paramount to the future of not only humankind but all alien races as well. He needs her help because in every single possible future he sees, she is there helping them getting to where they need to go – another planet, where the baby will be raised to become a positive leader for all. To convince her, Michael only needs to say that in all possible futures, Broken is flying once more. What he doesn’t tell her is that in some of the futures (the majority of them), they don’t succeed at all, the baby becomes yet another dictator and Michael ends up dead.

Broken is a dystopian novel, set in the future, after humankind have made First Contact and have started inhabiting other planets not with some degree with uneasiness when it comes to cohabiting with other races and cultures. Back at Earth where the story is set, the present is bleak and depressing and the world lives under a dictatorship that has “united” all the nations. Extrahumans are regarded with suspicion and must be affiliated to the Union, which is really under the control of the central government.

The first thing to be said about Broken is how there is very little exposition and info dump about the world and how it got to be how it is. Instead everything is shown and explored in the way that the characters interact with those they meet along the way; in Broken’s short flashbacks as her memories start to resurface; in the way that the streets, and dilapidated buildings are described and how the sense of being controlled and observed is present at every turn. I can’t begin to express how, Broken is a breath of fresh air especially after reading quite a few of (YA) “dystopian” novels lately where the reader is basically expected to simply accept the dystopian aspects of a world without any real exploration of all its elements and where there are no real consequences to a given character’s disregard to the rules within a particular world. In Broken, I felt the character’s fears (as well as fearing for them), the ever present danger and the bleakness of the world very deeply and that was one of the things I enjoyed the most about the novel.

My other favourite elements were the characters and their powers and how they related to each other and to the world they live in. The story alternates point of view between Broken and Michael and it follows both characters in their mission to save the future. There is a great juxtaposition between Broken and Michael for example: Broken is a former hero, Michael is just starting being one (although one can certainly argue about the extent of Broken’s heroics in the past so in a way perhaps she is really just starting, just like Michael); Broken is bitter about the past, Michael is bitter about the future. With regards to their powers, there is a lot of a sad irony when it comes to Broken because her other power is that of self-healing from any injury, including those that cause her own death, which means that she is never really broken forever, except for being unable to fly, the thing that matters the most to her. Michael on the other hand, can see the future, but not in the a straight, unique line for at any given time he is able to see several parallel futures at the same time, meaning that there is no predetermined future but different ones depending on the choices made by each character. This is probably the best thing about the novel (on top of everything else I already mentioned), that it is an exploration of heroism, of what it means to be a real hero in world that hates them, how to be a hero without having powers, how to be a hero having powers. Michael is super young and already saddled with such difficult choices: every time he looks in the mirror he sees his own possible futures and very few of them end up well, especially those relating to this very mission and yet he still chooses to undertake it. The fact that the author wrote a story in such a bleak world, and doesn’t really shy away from those bleak aspects (what an ending) but still managing to somehow convey hope is only the cherry on top.

Notable Quotes/ Parts:

She lay on her back, belly aching with hunger. Nearby, a pace–?bound ship heaved itself off the ground with a sigh and a groan, then sluggishly powered its way up towards the outer atmosphere and the vacuum beyond.

She followed its path with her finger, tracing the dissipating wake back and forth. Silverwyng had been more graceful by far.

Rating: 7 Very Good and leaning towards 8

Reading Next: Stories edited by Neil Gaiman and Al Sarrantonio

You Might Also Like


  • KMont
    March 18, 2011 at 7:58 am

    *I can’t begin to express how, Broken is a breath of fresh air especially after reading quite a few of (YA) “dystopian” novels lately where the reader is basically expected to simply accept the dystopian aspects of a world without any real exploration of all its elements and where there are no real consequences to a given character’s disregard to the rules within a particular world.*

    THIS makes my inner worldbuilding lover very happy to hear. If this isn’t in the dread All YAs Must Be Printed in Hardback format I might even read it soon!

  • KMont
    March 18, 2011 at 8:13 am

    OK, I don’t know why I thought this was YA. Gah, sorry for that goofup. Durr!

  • katiebabs
    March 18, 2011 at 8:24 am

    Sounds like a teen X-Men. No love triangle going on?

  • Ana
    March 18, 2011 at 8:28 am

    Kenda: LOL I think it is marketed as YA but I am not convinced it is, simply because Broken is an adult.

    KB: no love triangle, in fact, no romance at all.

  • Dominique
    March 18, 2011 at 8:38 am

    I’m really excited to read this! Finally, something with more depth than Twilight inspired YA! Any idea when this will be available on Amazon as a regular book? Only available in Kindle format right now…

  • Kate @ Candlemark
    March 18, 2011 at 9:25 am

    @Kenda: It’s kinda-sorta-not-really a YA. Neither the author nor I (hi, I’m the editor!) thought of it as a YA novel until reviewers started telling us it was one, and reviewing it as one. So…yeah, we’re kind of running with that, but it can really be read by just about anyone over age 14 or so.

    @katiebabs: No love triangle at all. Thank goodness.

    @dominique: We’re an e-publisher only at the moment, but we have Big Plans for Broken in the future…the author has already written another book set in this world, and we’re planning a huge to-do for that release, including releasing Broken in print alongside Fly Into Fire.

    (so yes, Ana, this IS the first in an ongoing world. The next book isn’t really a sequel, but it’s in the same world and explores some wonderful issues and ideas that were only touched upon in Broken. SO EXCITED about that one)

  • Ana
    March 18, 2011 at 9:39 am

    Kate: so happy about that!!! Can’t wait. This series has so much potential! :mrgreen:

  • Tipsy Reader
    March 18, 2011 at 2:35 pm

    Yay! I’m totally in love with the cover. Glad to hear it’s a good read too!

  • Samantha
    March 20, 2011 at 6:15 pm

    This sounds like an awesome read!!! I really need to get an ereader so I don’t miss out on books like this. Great review!

  • Smugglivus 2011 Guest Author: Susan Jane Bigelow | The Book Smugglers
    December 26, 2011 at 12:03 am

    […] Work: Broken, the first in the Extrahuman Union series and one of Ana’s Notable Reads of […]

  • Emila
    February 9, 2012 at 6:05 pm

    Winning the Web did rellay well. He is having another even bigger contest now.Tom Beaton’s last blog post..

  • A Smugglerific Cover: The Spark by Susan Jane Bigelow (& Giveaway of Broken) | The Book Smugglers
    April 12, 2012 at 12:01 am

    […] Extrahumans series is one of Ana’s current favourite Science Fiction series. The first book, Broken was one of her notable books of 2011 and the recently released Fly Into Fire, a tremendous […]

  • Dan Parenteau
    July 23, 2012 at 10:36 am

    I really appreciate the review, which was right on the money. I added Broken to my long list of books to read and when I finally got to it I was pleasantly surprised. I seems like more and more reviews on the web are, how do I put this, innacurate? Misrepresentative? Misleading?

    Broken was great, I also enjoyed Fly into Fire and I’m looking forward to Spark. Thank you so much for leading me to this great series and I sincerely hope that the author writes (and gets compensated) for years to come.

  • Reading The Spark by Susan Jane Bigelow: In which I urge our readers to read The Extrahumans Series | The Book Smugglers
    August 29, 2012 at 5:12 am

    […] did I read this book: I absolutely adored the first two books in the series: Broken (a Notable Read of 2011) and Fly Into Fire (a Notable Read of […]

  • Series Review: Extrahumans by Susan Jane Bigelow | Bunbury in the Stacks Series Review: Extrahumans by Susan Jane Bigelow | One has the right to Bunbury anywhere one chooses. Every serious Bunburyist knows that. ~ Oscar Wilde
    March 15, 2013 at 6:02 am

    […] a second opinion: The Book Smugglers reviewed Broken, Fly Into Fire, and The Spark Chronicles of a Book Evangelist reviewed […]

Leave a Reply